Elevate Your Culinary Experiences With Premium Wisconsin Cheeses
Step into Hill Valley Cheese Shop, a haven for cheese enthusiasts and curious taste adventurers alike
Discover both new and traditional cheeses
Support local Wisconsin producers
Share the love with unique gifts
Rediscover the Tradition of Handcrafted Cheese
In the fast-paced world of mass production, genuine connections to food and its makers have become rare and finding a local cheesemaker with a passion for quality ingredients can be even more elusive.
Taste, learn, and shop like never before
Whether you're a beginner or a cheese connoisseur, our shop offers something for everyone
Hand-picked selection
- Our cheesemongers personally curate our selection to bring you the best in artisanal, small batch cheeses from Wisconsin
Personalized tastings and pairing advice
- Come in for a tasting or contact us to learn about our Hill Valley Dairy cheeses and how they’re made, and let us help you find the perfect cheese and accompaniments for your next meal or gathering
Unique gifts and local products
- Looking for a special gift for the cheese lover in your life? We have a variety of unique gifts, including local products that pair perfectly with cheese
Three Steps To Cheese Nirvana
Visit And Discover
Come to our cheese shop to explore and learn about our artisanal selections
Select Your Favorites
Sample a variety of cheeses and choose the ones that speak to your palate
Share The Love
Take your cheeses home, share them with loved ones, and relive the experience of our cheese shop
Artisanal Excellence At Hill Valley Dairy
Discover award winner cheeses, locally crafted, focused on community and ethical practices.
Our Cheese Monger's Favorites
-
Bacon Cheddar
Regular price $10.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Black Pepper Cheddar
Regular price $9.00Regular priceUnit price per -
Garlic Dill Cheddar
Regular price $9.00Regular priceUnit price per
Take The First Step Towards A More Flavorful Life
- Taste the difference with our handcrafted selections
- Support local makers and be a part of a community that values tradition and quality
- Enjoy memorable experiences that rekindle the spirit of tradition and togetherness
Join our growing family of cheese enthusiasts
Awesome spot to relax and unwind. Atmosphere is great. Cheese boards are the best I’ve seen. Staff is extremely friendly and accommodating. Also check out their events, we had a blast. Highly recommend.
If you are looking for gourmet cheeses from famous cheese makers, this is THE place!! Here you can “up your cheese game” a bit.
Until you taste one of their offerings, you don’t know what you’ve been missing.
Ask for a sample le of something you are interested in.
Local Guide
This place was the top highlight of our day in Lake Geneva! The cheese board was wonderful and the wines! The service was awesome. We will definitely come back here every time we're in Lake Geneva! ❤️
Local Guide
My husband and I first fell in love with Hill Valley when they were at our local farmers market. We frequently would stop to get the dill cheese curds and gouda.
When we found out they had a shop and tasting room we couldnt resist! Had a great time sampling new cheeses. Nothing beats great product, locally made and terrific service. Looking forward to going back!
We visited the cheese bar recently and had an incredible time! Fantastic cheese served by fantastic people! Fun environment, delicious pairings, and overall a great way to spend an evening.
Send A Message
Fill out the form below with your message and someone from our team will respond soon.